Files
ai-app/docs/SUBAGENTS.md
T
irisandClaude Opus 5 4ccfda6b8e Delete the decisions and design logs; scripts, rigs and xtask off the root
Iris: "remove both decisions and iris.md. I've decided to instead make
decisions when planning with agents rather than after they do things, and
they're both too long for me to wanna read, + don't cover all the
decisions I'll wanna make about the code anyways. I'll just naturally run
into things for now. Todo is important though."

So docs/DECISIONS.md (850 lines) and docs/IRIS.md (1,986) are gone, and
AGENTS.md now says not to start another: raise a choice while planning it
with her, otherwise decide it and put the reasoning at the code it
governs. The TODO lists stay. docs/SUBAGENTS_DECISIONS.md went with them
-- same artefact, same reasoning, and she did not name it, so its six
decisions were folded into docs/SUBAGENTS.md rather than deleted.

Deleting the logs left ~30 citations dangling in code comments and docs.
Each states its reason inline and cited the file only for provenance, so
they now read "decided 2026-09-07" or name the module doc that carries
the reasoning.

The root had six things that were not a program or a document. Moved,
per "I only meant top level sh files":

  run-tests.sh, test-wg-tunnel.sh, wg-setup-host.sh  -> scripts/
  rigs/                                              -> scripts/rigs/
  xtask/                                             -> scripts/xtask/

A project's own scripts stayed with the project: app/*.sh, app-rust/*.sh,
iris/*.sh and server/enroll-link.sh did not move.

`target/` at the root is deleted and cannot come back: there was never a
workspace there, and the 29 MB was only xtask's scratch space, now in
scripts/xtask/target/. `cargo xtask apk` still runs from the repo root
and now publishes to scripts/build/outputs/apk/<mode>/ -- one directory
deep, because that is what Dev Updater's `*/build/outputs/apk/*/*.apk`
discovery pattern needs, and scripts/xtask/build would have been two.

Verified: ./scripts/run-tests.sh and `cd iris && cargo test` green, clippy
and fmt clean everywhere, `cargo xtask apk debug --abi x86_64` builds and
signs an APK carrying lib/x86_64/libai_app.so at the new publish path, and
the repo root is now eleven entries with no build output among them.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-09 00:16:24 -04:00

182 lines
9.5 KiB
Markdown

# Subagents
A session's subagents -- the helpers a Claude Code session starts through its
Task tool -- each get a transcript of their own, listed under the session's
card and readable in the same transcript view the session has. Designed
2026-09-05; the choices behind it are at the bottom of this file.
## What a subagent is here
**A subagent is a second transcript owned by a session, in the same event
model, with no process and no controls.** It is not a session: it cannot be
messaged, stopped or started, and it has no setup, model or usage of its
own. Everything it shares with a session -- the transcript file format, the
paging routes, the SSE stream, the phone's cache and rendering -- is reused
by addressing, not by copying.
The CLI reports a subagent's messages on the parent's own stream-json
output, each carrying `parent_tool_use_id` = the id of the Task `tool_use`
that started it. Before this the translator dropped those lines
(`subagent_events_are_not_duplicated_into_the_transcript`); now it routes
them to that subagent's own translator and transcript. The parent's
transcript still shows only the Task call itself.
## Storage
Under the session directory:
```
<session>/subagents/<tool_use_id>/meta.json {title, created}
<session>/subagents/<tool_use_id>/transcript.jsonl same SeqEvent lines as the session's
```
The id is the Task tool_use id (`toolu_…`), which is unique, stable across a
backend restart, and already the key everything on the parent side uses.
Only ids matching `[A-Za-z0-9_-]+` are ever created or looked up, since the
id becomes a path.
The transcript's sequence numbers are its own, starting at 1. `Transcript`,
`read_window`, `catch_up` and `read_after` work on it unchanged.
Its path out: deleting the session deletes its directory, subagents included.
There is no separate delete.
## Lifecycle, as events in the subagent's transcript
1. Created on the first child line for an unseen parent id (or, when the
parent Task call was seen, at that call). First lines written:
`Status Running`, then `UserMessage { text: <the Task's prompt> }` when
the prompt is known -- it genuinely is the subagent's first user turn.
2. Every child line is translated by that subagent's own `Translator`
(one per subagent: tool ids are unique but streaming deltas are by
content-block index, and parallel subagents interleave).
3. **The parent's `tool_result` never finishes a subagent.** The Task tool
runs in the background by default: the `tool_result` -- "Async agent
launched..." -- arrives the moment it *starts*, while the subagent goes
on working for however long its own turn takes, sometimes minutes. What
ends it is its own turn ending: the raw API's `message_delta` on its
stream carrying `stop_reason: "end_turn"` (a `stop_reason` of `tool_use`
is the model about to call one, not an end), or a `result` line for its
own turn if a future CLI version ever sends one. Either maps to
`Status Exited`; the subagent's vocabulary has no `Idle`, so the
equivalent event `dispatch` produces for an ordinary session is dropped
rather than written. A shipped version of this finished on the
`tool_result` instead, which read a running background agent as
"finished" with its transcript truncated at the moment it launched.
4. **A child line for a subagent that already finished reopens it**
(`Status Running`) rather than being dropped: a background Task can be
sent another message long after its first turn ended, and that is
exactly what a further line for it means. Same transcript, same child
`Translator`, just picking back up.
5. When the parent session's process exits (`Status Exited` on the
session), every subagent still `Running` gets `Status Exited` too: its
process was the parent's.
A subagent that was mid-flight when the backend restarted keeps working:
the registry reopens the existing transcript on the next child line, and
the file continues its sequence -- the same reopening #4 describes, whether
what closed it was a restart or its own `end_turn`. If its turn ended while
the backend was down nothing recorded that until the next line arrives, so
its last status stays `Running`, which the list reports as **unknown**
rather than as running (see the wire shape) until then.
Title: the Task call's `description` input, then ` (<subagent_type>)` when
one is given; falling back to the tool's name when the child arrives before
(or without) the parent call being seen.
## Server layout
- `session/subagent.rs` -- the registry: `Subagents` (per session, in
`Shared`), `Subagent` (its `Transcript` behind a mutex plus a
`broadcast::Sender<SeqEvent>`), `record(id, event)`, `start(id, title,
prompt)`, `finish(id)`, `reopen(id)`, `finish_all()`, `list()` from disk. Drivers get an
`Arc<Subagents>` beside their `EventSink`; llama ignores it.
- `session/claude/translate.rs` -- routes child lines by parent id, holds
one child `Translator` per subagent, remembers pending Task calls'
description/prompt/subagent_type.
- `session/echo.rs` -- `/subagent [n]`: the test rig. Starts *n* (default 1)
subagents at once, each named "helper k". Each writes the prompt as its
user message, streams a few words of text, runs one `Bash` tool call, then
finishes about three seconds after starting, and the parent's Task calls
end when their subagent does. Three seconds so the running state can be
seen on the phone.
- `routes.rs` -- three routes, in the doc table.
## Wire shape
```
GET /sessions/{id} SessionInfo gains `subagents: N` (count, 0 when none)
GET /sessions same field on each row
GET /sessions/{id}/subagents [{id, title, status, created, lastActivity}], oldest first
GET /sessions/{id}/subagents/{sub}/transcript exactly the session transcript's query and answer
GET /sessions/{id}/subagents/{sub}/events?after=N exactly the session events stream
```
`status` is the transcript's last `Status` event, serialised like a session's
(`running`, `exited`), except that a subagent whose session is not itself
running cannot be running: the list answers `unknown` for that one. The
phone words these as *running*, *finished* and *unknown* on the subcard.
The count on `SessionInfo` is a directory listing, so the list stays cheap.
The per-subagent status is only read when the list route is asked for.
## Phone
- `SessionSummary.subagents: Int`. A card with a non-zero count ends in an
expander row -- a full-width `Chevron(Pointing.Down)` row that flips to
`Pointing.Up` -- collapsed by default. Expanding fetches
`/sessions/{id}/subagents` and draws one `OutlinedCard` per subagent,
indented inside the session card, the way dev-updater draws a project's
components: title, then the status word and a relative time. The
expansion state is per session id and survives a refresh of the list.
- Tapping a subcard opens `Screen.Subagent`, which is `SessionScreen` in
**read-only** form: the same transcript, paging, cache, selection,
images and status row, with the composer, the process button, the model
picker, the files button, the settings cog and the usage bar left out.
The header shows the subagent's title with the session's title beneath
it. Back returns to the list.
- Addressing: `fetchTranscript`, `EventStream`, `TranscriptSource` and the
cache take a transcript address rather than a session id --
`sessions/{id}` or `sessions/{id}/subagents/{sub}` -- so the cache nests a
subagent's copy under its session's and the same code serves both.
## The choices behind the shape, and what they rejected
Made without asking, each with limited blast radius:
1. **A subagent is a transcript, not a session.** It has no process,
controls or settings; it is addressed as `/sessions/{id}/subagents/{sub}`
and stored under the session's directory, so deleting the session takes
it. Alternative rejected: registering it as a session of its own, which
would give it a card in the main list and a driver that can do nothing.
2. **Read-only view is the session screen minus its controls**, rather than
a second, simpler transcript screen. Keeps paging, caching, selection
and rendering in one place. Cost: a `readOnly` mode threaded through
`SessionScreen`.
3. **The list only carries a count.** Each session row says how many
subagents it has; their titles and statuses are fetched when the card is
expanded. Keeps `GET /sessions` from reading every subagent transcript.
Consequence: an expanded card's statuses refresh with the list, not live.
4. **Expanded/collapsed is remembered per session on the phone**, not on
the server. Collapsed by default, per the transcript convention that new
things arrive collapsed.
5. **Subagents of imported sessions are not shown.** The import path still
skips `isSidechain` records; the CLI's own `subagents/agent-*.jsonl` files
are not read. Only subagents run while this backend was watching exist.
6. **Echo grows `/subagent [n]`** as the test rig, so nothing here needs a
paid turn to exercise.
Deferred, because they reach further than this feature:
- **Live status on the list.** Whether the session list should follow a
stream at all (it refreshes on demand today) decides whether subagent
status can ever be live there. Not changed.
- **Nested subagents.** A subagent's own Task calls are shown as tool calls
in its transcript and are not given transcripts of their own. Supporting
that is the same mechanism one level down, but the UI would need nested
expanders.
- **The subagent status row says "context unknown".** Nothing measures a
subagent's context; the row could leave it out rather than admit it.